Creamy Peanut Butter product image with 30/100 Zerotox safety score

Is Creamy Peanut Butter Safe? Ingredient Analysis

Big Y

Creamy Peanut Butter is one of the food products analyzed by Zerotox for Big Y. The product scores 30/100 in Zerotox, meaning it has several flagged ingredients and may not suit cautious buyers.

The sections below explain why ingredients like Corn Syrup, Hydrogenated Rapeseed And Cottonseed Oils affect the overall evaluation.

30 / 100

Low quality

Why score is 30

The composition includes roasted peanuts, which are a natural ingredient, but also contains corn syrup and hydrogenated oils. Corn syrup is a refined sweetener that raises quality concerns, while hydrogenated oils indicate processing and potential trans fat presence, lowering the overall safety assessment.

Main concern

Includes corn syrup, a refined sweetener that raises quality concerns.

Why it matters: This ingredient is flagged in our analysis based on regulatory and scientific sources. Check the Ingredients section for details and see Data sources for methodology.

Regulation status: Ingredient safety is assessed from EU/EPA/CIR and similar databases; formulations may vary. Always read the product label.

Pros

  • Contains roasted peanuts, a natural ingredient providing flavor and texture.

Concerns

  • Includes corn syrup, a refined sweetener that raises quality concerns.
  • Hydrogenated oils may contain trans fats, which are associated with health risks.

Who should avoid this product?

This product may be less suitable for:

  • people with sensitive skin or fragrance sensitivity

Ingredients breakdown

Instead of a flat list, this section explains each ingredient in the context of this food.

  • Is Roasted Peanuts safe in this food?

    Good

    Roasted Peanuts is used here as base. Roasted peanuts are the primary ingredient, providing natural flavor and texture. They are minimally processed and contribute healthy fats and protein, supporting the product's overall quality.

    Role in formula: base

    Original: ROASTED PEANUTS

    Read the full ingredient profile for Roasted Peanuts

  • Is Corn Syrup safe in this food?

    Bad

    Corn Syrup is used here as sweetener. Corn syrup is a highly processed sweetener used to enhance sweetness and texture. Its presence raises concerns about added sugars and potential health implications associated with excessive consumption.

    Role in formula: sweetener

    Original: CORN SYRUP

    Read the full ingredient profile for Corn Syrup

  • Is Hydrogenated Rapeseed And Cottonseed Oils safe in this food?

    Bad

    Hydrogenated Rapeseed And Cottonseed Oils is used here as emulsifier. Hydrogenated oils are used to improve texture and shelf stability. However, they may contain trans fats, which are linked to various health risks, thus negatively impacting the product's safety profile.

    Role in formula: emulsifier

    Original: HYDROGENATED RAPESEED AND COTTONSEED OILS

  • Is Salt safe in this food?

    Good

    Salt is used here as flavor. Salt is added to enhance flavor in this peanut butter. It is a common ingredient that contributes to taste without raising significant safety concerns when used in moderation.

    Role in formula: flavor

    Original: SALT

    Read the full ingredient profile for Salt

How we score

Our safety scores and ingredient breakdowns are based on regulatory and scientific sources. See Data sources & methodology and How Zerotox works for full details.

Product info

Product ID: 2385702

More from this brand: Big Y products in Zerotox

Similar products: food in Zerotox database

Allergens detected: peanut

Report / complain: You may report errors or complain about this product or its formulation to hello [at] zeroto.app . Published for transparency.

Frequently asked questions

This product includes positive or neutral ingredients such as: roasted peanuts, salt. See the Ingredients section above.
Big Y — Creamy Peanut Butter has a Zerotox score of 30 / 100 among food products. See the full breakdown above.
Browse Big Y products on Zerotox with ingredient analysis and safety scores.
Big Y — Creamy Peanut Butter has a Zerotox safety score of 30 / 100. Higher scores mean fewer concerning ingredients. Scores are informational only and do not constitute professional advice; always read the label and consult a qualified professional.
We do not detect parabens in this product's listed ingredients. Always check the label as formulations change.
Zerotox gives Big Y — Creamy Peanut Butter 30 / 100 based on ingredients. Ultra-processed foods often have many additives; see the breakdown above. Scores are informational only and do not constitute professional advice; always read the label and consult a qualified professional.
We detected: peanut. If you have allergies, check the label and the Ingredients section above.
This depends on the ingredient profile. People with sensitive skin or scalp, users avoiding fragrance, sulfates or animal-derived ingredients, and cautious shoppers should review the breakdown above before buying. Scores are informational only and do not constitute professional advice; always read the label and consult a qualified professional.
Big Y — Creamy Peanut Butter has a Zerotox safety score of 30 / 100. Check the ingredient breakdown above. More Big Y products. Scores are informational only and do not constitute professional advice; always read the label and consult a qualified professional.
Our analysis notes: Contains roasted peanuts, a natural ingredient providing flavor and texture.. See the Pros section above.
Check the Ingredients section above. Zerotox flags preservatives, colours and other additives; see the full list.
Main concerns for this product: Includes corn syrup, a refined sweetener that raises quality concerns.; Hydrogenated oils may contain trans fats, which are associated with health risks.. See the full list above.

Safer alternatives from Big Y

These same-brand alternatives currently score higher and may fit cautious buyers better: