Is Frosted Sugar Cookies Safe? Ingredient Analysis
Favorite Day Bakery
Favorite Day Bakery's Frosted Sugar Cookies is reviewed here as a snack. Zerotox gives it 30/100 based on the current ingredient profile, so it has several flagged ingredients and may not suit cautious buyers.
The ingredient review below focuses especially on Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate, Shellac, Red 40 Lake.
30 / 100
Why score is 30
The composition includes several synthetic additives such as artificial colors (Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5 Lake) and preservatives (sodium bicarbonate). These raise significant quality concerns.
Main concern
Presence of multiple artificial colors (Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5 Lake) raises safety concerns regarding synthetic additives.
Why it matters: This ingredient is flagged in our analysis based on regulatory and scientific sources. Check the Ingredients section for details and see Data sources for methodology.
Regulation status: Ingredient safety is assessed from EU/EPA/CIR and similar databases; formulations may vary. Always read the product label.
Pros
- Contains enriched flour providing some essential nutrients like niacin and iron.
- Includes chocolate chips which add flavor and texture to the cookies.
Concerns
- Presence of multiple artificial colors (Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5 Lake) raises safety concerns regarding synthetic additives.
- Includes palm oil and soy lecithin, which are often criticized for environmental and health impacts.
Who should avoid this product?
This formula may not suit:
- people with sensitive skin or fragrance sensitivity
- users trying to avoid sulfates
- people avoiding animal-derived ingredients
Ingredients breakdown
Below, each ingredient is described in the context of this snack, not just listed as a raw label.
-
Is Sugar safe in this snack?
Medium
Sugar is used here as sweetener. Sugar is used for sweetness in these cookies, but its high consumption is linked to various health concerns.
Role in formula: sweetener
Original: sugar
-
Is Enriched Flour safe in this snack?
Medium
Enriched Flour is used here as base. Enriched flour provides some nutrients but is highly processed, raising concerns about its overall health impact.
Role in formula: base
Original: enriched flour
-
Is Bleached Wheat Flour safe in this snack?
Medium
Bleached Wheat Flour is used here as base. Bleached wheat flour is processed to improve texture and appearance, but bleaching agents may raise health concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: bleached wheat flour
-
Is Niacin safe in this snack?
Good
Niacin is used here as base. Niacin is a B vitamin that supports metabolism and is beneficial in small amounts, contributing positively to the product.
Role in formula: base
Original: niacin
-
Is Reduced Iron safe in this snack?
Good
Reduced Iron is used here as base. Reduced iron is added as a nutrient to enhance iron content, which is beneficial for those with iron deficiency.
Role in formula: base
Original: reduced iron
-
Is Thiamine Mononitrate safe in this snack?
Good
Thiamine Mononitrate is used here as base. Thiamine is a B vitamin that supports energy metabolism, contributing positively to the nutritional profile.
Role in formula: base
Original: thiamine mononitrate
-
Is Riboflavin safe in this snack?
Good
Riboflavin is used here as base. Riboflavin is a B vitamin that plays a role in energy production and is beneficial in small amounts.
Role in formula: base
Original: riboflavin
-
Is Folic Acid safe in this snack?
Good
Folic Acid is used here as base. Folic acid is important for DNA synthesis and cell division, contributing positively to the product's nutritional value.
Role in formula: base
Original: folic acid
-
Is Palm Oil safe in this snack?
Medium
Palm Oil is used here as base. Palm oil is used for texture and moisture but raises concerns due to environmental impact and health implications.
Role in formula: base
Original: palm oil
-
Is Water safe in this snack?
Good
Water is used here as base. Water is a necessary ingredient for hydration and texture in baked goods, posing no quality concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: water
-
Is Eggs safe in this snack?
Good
Eggs is used here as base. Eggs provide structure and moisture, and they are a source of protein and essential nutrients.
Role in formula: base
Original: eggs
-
Is Chocolate Chips safe in this snack?
Medium
Chocolate Chips is used here as flavor. Chocolate chips add flavor and texture but may contain added sugars and fats, raising some quality concerns.
Role in formula: flavor
Original: chocolate chips
-
Is Chocolate Liquor safe in this snack?
Medium
Chocolate Liquor is used here as flavor. Chocolate liquor contributes to flavor but is a processed ingredient that may raise concerns about quality.
Role in formula: flavor
Original: chocolate liquor
-
Is Cocoa Butter safe in this snack?
Medium
Cocoa Butter is used here as flavor. Cocoa butter adds richness and flavor but is a processed fat, which may raise health concerns.
Role in formula: flavor
Original: cocoa butter
-
Is Soy Lecithin safe in this snack?
Medium
Soy Lecithin is used here as emulsifier. Soy lecithin is used as an emulsifier to improve texture but is a processed ingredient with mixed health implications.
Role in formula: emulsifier
Original: soy lecithin
-
Is Natural Flavor safe in this snack?
Medium
Natural Flavor is used here as flavor. Natural flavor is used to enhance taste but can be vague in terms of specific ingredients and quality.
Role in formula: flavor
Original: natural flavor
-
Is Cocoa safe in this snack?
Good
Cocoa is used here as flavor. Cocoa adds flavor and some antioxidants, contributing positively to the product's profile.
Role in formula: flavor
Original: cocoa
-
Is Whey safe in this snack?
Medium
Whey is used here as base. Whey is a dairy byproduct that adds protein but may raise concerns for those with lactose intolerance.
Role in formula: base
Original: whey
-
Is Milk safe in this snack?
Medium
Milk is used here as base. Milk adds moisture and flavor but may pose issues for lactose-intolerant individuals.
Role in formula: base
Original: milk
-
Is Salt safe in this snack?
Good
Salt is used here as base. Salt enhances flavor and is essential for taste, posing no significant quality concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: salt
-
Is Baking Soda safe in this snack?
Medium
Baking Soda is used here as leavening. Baking soda is a leavening agent that helps the cookies rise but is a processed ingredient.
Role in formula: leavening
Original: baking soda
-
Is Cornstarch safe in this snack?
Medium
Cornstarch is used here as thickener. Cornstarch is used for texture but is a processed ingredient that may raise quality concerns.
Role in formula: thickener
Original: cornstarch
-
Is Leavening safe in this snack?
Medium
Leavening is used here as leavening. Leavening agents help the cookies rise but can be processed and raise quality concerns.
Role in formula: leavening
Original: leavening
-
Is Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate safe in this snack?
Bad
Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate is used here as leavening. Sodium acid pyrophosphate is a synthetic leavening agent that raises concerns about artificial additives.
Role in formula: leavening
Original: sodium acid pyrophosphate
Read the full ingredient profile for Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate
-
Is Sodium Bicarbonate safe in this snack?
Medium
Sodium Bicarbonate is used here as leavening. Sodium bicarbonate is a common leavening agent but is a processed ingredient that may raise quality concerns.
Role in formula: leavening
Original: sodium bicarbonate
-
Is Monocalcium Phosphate safe in this snack?
Medium
Monocalcium Phosphate is used here as leavening. Monocalcium phosphate is a leavening agent that can be synthetic, raising concerns about quality.
Role in formula: leavening
Original: monocalcium phosphate
-
Is Calcium Sulfate safe in this snack?
Medium
Calcium Sulfate is used here as thickener. Calcium sulfate is used as a thickener but is a processed ingredient that may raise quality concerns.
Role in formula: thickener
Original: calcium sulfate
-
Is Maltodextrin safe in this snack?
Medium
Maltodextrin is used here as thickener. Maltodextrin is a processed thickener that can raise concerns about its impact on blood sugar levels.
Role in formula: thickener
Original: maltodextrin
-
Is Soy Flour safe in this snack?
Medium
Soy Flour is used here as base. Soy flour adds protein and texture but is a processed ingredient that may raise quality concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: soy flour
-
Is Vegetable Oils safe in this snack?
Medium
Vegetable Oils is used here as base. Vegetable oils are used for moisture but can be highly processed, raising health concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: vegetable oils
-
Is Palm And Soybean Oil safe in this snack?
Medium
Palm And Soybean Oil is used here as base. Palm and soybean oil are used for texture but raise concerns regarding health and environmental impact.
Role in formula: base
Original: palm and soybean oil
-
Is Skimmed Milk Powder safe in this snack?
Medium
Skimmed Milk Powder is used here as base. Skimmed milk powder adds flavor and nutrients but may pose issues for lactose-intolerant individuals.
Role in formula: base
Original: skimmed milk powder
-
Is Corn Oil safe in this snack?
Medium
Corn Oil is used here as base. Corn oil is used for moisture but is a processed ingredient that may raise health concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: corn oil
-
Is Shellac safe in this snack?
Bad
Shellac is used here as coating. Shellac is a resin used as a coating agent, raising concerns due to its synthetic nature and potential health risks.
Role in formula: coating
Original: shellac
-
Is Red 40 Lake safe in this snack?
Bad
Red 40 Lake is used here as colorant. Red 40 Lake is an artificial colorant linked to potential health risks, raising significant quality concerns.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: red 40 lake
-
Is Yellow 5 Lake safe in this snack?
Bad
Yellow 5 Lake is used here as colorant. Yellow 5 Lake is an artificial colorant associated with health concerns, contributing negatively to the product's quality.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: yellow 5 lake
-
Is Yellow 6 Lake safe in this snack?
Bad
Yellow 6 Lake is used here as colorant. Yellow 6 Lake is an artificial colorant that raises health concerns, indicating a lower quality composition.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: yellow 6 lake
-
Is Carnauba Wax safe in this snack?
Medium
Carnauba Wax is used here as coating. Carnauba wax is used for coating but is a processed ingredient that may raise quality concerns.
Role in formula: coating
Original: carnauba wax
-
Is Blue 1 Lake safe in this snack?
Bad
Blue 1 Lake is used here as colorant. Blue 1 Lake is an artificial colorant linked to potential health risks, raising significant quality concerns.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: blue 1 lake
-
Is Red 40 safe in this snack?
Bad
Red 40 is used here as colorant. Red 40 is an artificial colorant associated with health concerns, contributing negatively to the product's quality.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: red 40
How we score
Our safety scores and ingredient breakdowns are based on regulatory and scientific sources. See Data sources & methodology and How Zerotox works for full details.
Product info
Product ID: 3334279
More from this brand: Favorite Day Bakery products in Zerotox
Similar products: snack in Zerotox database
Allergens detected: milk , egg , soy
Report / complain: You may report errors or complain about this product or its formulation to hello [at] zeroto.app . Published for transparency.