Is Picklee Herring Safe? Ingredient Analysis
Lisner
Lisner's Picklee Herring is reviewed here as a food. Zerotox gives it 60/100 based on the current ingredient profile, so it looks generally acceptable but still includes some ingredients worth reviewing.
The ingredient review below focuses especially on Sodium Benzoate.
60 / 100
Why score is 60
The composition includes herring fillets and marinated onion, but also contains sodium benzoate as a preservative, raising quality concerns about synthetic additives.
Main concern
Sodium benzoate is a synthetic preservative that raises concerns about the presence of artificial additives.
Why it matters: This ingredient is flagged in our analysis based on regulatory and scientific sources. Check the Ingredients section for details and see Data sources for methodology.
Regulation status: Ingredient safety is assessed from EU/EPA/CIR and similar databases; formulations may vary. Always read the product label.
Pros
- Herring fillets provide a source of omega-3 fatty acids, contributing to overall nutritional value.
- Marinated onion adds flavor and may enhance the sensory experience of the product.
Concerns
- Sodium benzoate is a synthetic preservative that raises concerns about the presence of artificial additives.
- The inclusion of sugar may indicate a higher level of processing, which can detract from overall quality.
Who should avoid this product?
This formula may not suit:
- people with sensitive skin or fragrance sensitivity
- people avoiding animal-derived ingredients
Ingredients breakdown
Below, each ingredient is described in the context of this food, not just listed as a raw label.
-
Is Herring Fillets safe in this food?
Good
Herring Fillets is used here as base. Herring fillets are a natural source of protein and omega-3 fatty acids, contributing positively to the product's nutritional profile.
Role in formula: base
Original: Herring fillets (50%) (Clupea harengus)*
-
Is Water safe in this food?
Good
Water is used here as base. Water serves as a solvent and base for the product, ensuring proper texture and consistency without quality concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: water
-
Is Marinated Onion safe in this food?
Medium
Marinated Onion is used here as flavor. Marinated onion adds flavor and acidity, but the processing may raise concerns about the quality of the ingredient.
Role in formula: flavor
Original: marinated onion (20%)
-
Is Sugar safe in this food?
Medium
Sugar is used here as sweetener. Sugar is used for flavor enhancement but contributes to a more processed profile, which may not align with clean eating preferences.
Role in formula: sweetener
Original: sugar
-
Is Salt safe in this food?
Good
Salt is used here as flavor. Salt is a natural flavor enhancer and preservative, essential for balancing flavors in this product.
Role in formula: flavor
Original: salt
-
Is Vinegar safe in this food?
Good
Vinegar is used here as acidulant. Vinegar acts as an acidulant, providing tanginess and helping to preserve the product naturally.
Role in formula: acidulant
Original: vinegar
-
Is Acetic Acid safe in this food?
Medium
Acetic Acid is used here as acidulant. Acetic acid is used to regulate acidity, but its synthetic nature raises some quality concerns.
Role in formula: acidulant
Original: acidity regulator (acetic acid)
-
Is Sodium Benzoate safe in this food?
Bad
Sodium Benzoate is used here as preservative. Sodium benzoate is a synthetic preservative that helps prevent spoilage but raises concerns about synthetic additives in food.
Role in formula: preservative
Original: preservative (sodium benzoate)
How we score
Our safety scores and ingredient breakdowns are based on regulatory and scientific sources. See Data sources & methodology and How Zerotox works for full details.
Product info
Product ID: 4007617
More from this brand: Lisner products in Zerotox
Similar products: food in Zerotox database
Allergens detected: crustaceans , gluten , eggs , mustard , milk , celery , soya
Report / complain: You may report errors or complain about this product or its formulation to hello [at] zeroto.app . Published for transparency.