Is Frosted Sugar Cookies Safe? Ingredient Analysis
Bakery Fresh Goodness
Bakery Fresh Goodness's Frosted Sugar Cookies is reviewed here as a dessert. Zerotox gives it 30/100 based on the current ingredient profile, so it has several flagged ingredients and may not suit cautious buyers.
The ingredient review below focuses especially on Sodium Aluminum Sulfate, Polysorbate 60, Blue 1 Lake.
30 / 100
Why score is 30
The composition of these cookies includes several synthetic additives such as sodium propionate (preservative), artificial flavors, and multiple artificial colors (e.g., Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5 Lake). These ingredients indicate a highly processed product with significant quality and safety concerns, contributing to the low rating.
Main concern
Contains sodium propionate, a synthetic preservative that raises concerns about artificial additives in food.
Why it matters: This ingredient is flagged in our analysis based on regulatory and scientific sources. Check the Ingredients section for details and see Data sources for methodology.
Regulation status: Ingredient safety is assessed from EU/EPA/CIR and similar databases; formulations may vary. Always read the product label.
Pros
- Contains enriched bleached flour, providing some essential nutrients like niacin and folic acid.
- Includes eggs, which contribute to texture and structure in baked goods.
Concerns
- Contains sodium propionate, a synthetic preservative that raises concerns about artificial additives in food.
- Includes multiple artificial colors (e.g., Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5 Lake), which are associated with potential sensitivity issues.
Who should avoid this product?
This formula may not suit:
- people with sensitive skin or fragrance sensitivity
- users trying to avoid sulfates
- people avoiding animal-derived ingredients
Ingredients breakdown
Below, each ingredient is described in the context of this dessert, not just listed as a raw label.
-
Is Sugar safe in this dessert?
Medium
Sugar is used here as sweetener. Sugar is a common sweetener that enhances flavor and texture in baked goods. However, its high glycemic index raises concerns about excessive consumption.
Role in formula: sweetener
Original: sugar
-
Is Enriched Bleached Flour safe in this dessert?
Medium
Enriched Bleached Flour is used here as base. Enriched bleached flour is processed wheat flour with added nutrients. While it provides some vitamins, the bleaching process raises concerns about processing.
Role in formula: base
Original: enriched bleached flour (wheat flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamin mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid)
Read the full ingredient profile for Enriched Bleached Flour
-
Is Margarine safe in this dessert?
Medium
Margarine is used here as base. Margarine is a spread made from vegetable oils. It contains palm oil and artificial flavor, raising concerns about trans fats and synthetic additives.
Role in formula: base
Original: margarine (palm oil, water, soybean oil, salt, contains 2% or less of: mono - and diglycerides, calcium disodium edta [preservative], artificial flavor, annatto t [color], vitamin a palmitate)
-
Is Eggs safe in this dessert?
Good
Eggs is used here as base. Eggs provide structure and moisture in baked goods. They are a natural ingredient that contributes to the overall quality of the product.
Role in formula: base
Original: eggs
-
Is Water safe in this dessert?
Good
Water is used here as base. Water is a fundamental ingredient in baking, necessary for hydration and the formation of dough. It poses no quality concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: water
-
Is Corn Starch safe in this dessert?
Medium
Corn Starch is used here as thickener. Corn starch is used as a thickening agent in baked goods. While it is a common ingredient, it is often highly processed.
Role in formula: thickener
Original: corn starch
-
Is Palm Kernel Oil safe in this dessert?
Medium
Palm Kernel Oil is used here as base. Palm kernel oil is a vegetable oil that contributes to texture. Its production raises environmental sustainability concerns.
Role in formula: base
Original: palm kernel oil
-
Is Baking Soda safe in this dessert?
Good
Baking Soda is used here as leavening. Baking soda is a leavening agent that helps baked goods rise. It is a common and safe ingredient in baking.
Role in formula: leavening
Original: baking soda
-
Is Sodium Aluminum Sulfate safe in this dessert?
Bad
Sodium Aluminum Sulfate is used here as leavening. Sodium aluminum sulfate is a leavening agent that raises concerns due to its aluminum content, which may pose health risks.
Role in formula: leavening
Original: sodium aluminum sulfate
Read the full ingredient profile for Sodium Aluminum Sulfate
-
Is Monocalcium Phosphate safe in this dessert?
Medium
Monocalcium Phosphate is used here as leavening. Monocalcium phosphate is a leavening agent that helps baked goods rise. It is generally recognized as safe but is a processed ingredient.
Role in formula: leavening
Original: monocalcium phosphate
-
Is Modified Corn Starch safe in this dessert?
Medium
Modified Corn Starch is used here as thickener. Modified corn starch is used as a thickening agent. Its processing raises concerns about the quality of the ingredient.
Role in formula: thickener
Original: modified corn starch
-
Is Polysorbate 60 safe in this dessert?
Bad
Polysorbate 60 is used here as emulsifier. Polysorbate 60 is a synthetic emulsifier that helps blend ingredients. Its synthetic nature raises quality concerns.
Role in formula: emulsifier
Original: polysorbate 60
-
Is Blue 1 Lake safe in this dessert?
Bad
Blue 1 Lake is used here as colorant. Blue 1 Lake is an artificial colorant used for visual appeal. Synthetic dyes like this are associated with potential sensitivity issues.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: blue 1 lake
-
Is Yellow 5 Lake safe in this dessert?
Bad
Yellow 5 Lake is used here as colorant. Yellow 5 Lake is an artificial colorant that raises concerns about potential allergic reactions and sensitivity in some individuals.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: yellow 5 lake
-
Is Red 40 Lake safe in this dessert?
Bad
Red 40 Lake is used here as colorant. Red 40 Lake is an artificial colorant linked to potential hyperactivity in children and other sensitivity issues.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: red 40 lake
-
Is Yellow 6 Lake safe in this dessert?
Bad
Yellow 6 Lake is used here as colorant. Yellow 6 Lake is an artificial colorant that may cause allergic reactions in sensitive individuals, raising quality concerns.
Role in formula: colorant
Original: yellow 6 lake
-
Is Natural And Artificial Flavors safe in this dessert?
Bad
Natural And Artificial Flavors is used here as flavor. Natural and artificial flavors are used to enhance taste but can be vague in origin, raising concerns about transparency and quality.
Role in formula: flavor
Original: natural and artificial flavors
Read the full ingredient profile for Natural And Artificial Flavors
-
Is Nonfat Milk safe in this dessert?
Good
Nonfat Milk is used here as base. Nonfat milk adds moisture and flavor to baked goods. It is a natural ingredient that contributes positively to the product's quality.
Role in formula: base
Original: nonfat milk
-
Is Soy Lecithin safe in this dessert?
Medium
Soy Lecithin is used here as emulsifier. Soy lecithin is a natural emulsifier that helps blend ingredients. While it is derived from soy, it is often processed.
Role in formula: emulsifier
Original: soy lecithin
-
Is Dextrin safe in this dessert?
Medium
Dextrin is used here as thickener. Dextrin is a thickening agent derived from starch. Its processing raises concerns about the quality of the ingredient.
Role in formula: thickener
Original: dextrin
-
Is Sunflower Lecithin safe in this dessert?
Medium
Sunflower Lecithin is used here as emulsifier. Sunflower lecithin is a natural emulsifier that helps stabilize the mixture. It is generally considered safe but is processed.
Role in formula: emulsifier
Original: sunflower lecithin
-
Is Carnauba Wax safe in this dessert?
Bad
Carnauba Wax is used here as coating. Carnauba wax is used as a coating agent. While it is plant-derived, its use in food raises questions about safety and processing.
Role in formula: coating
Original: carnauba wax
-
Is Confectioner S Glaze safe in this dessert?
Bad
Confectioner S Glaze is used here as coating. Confectioner's glaze is a coating that can contain shellac, raising concerns about its safety and suitability for consumption.
Role in formula: coating
Original: confectioner's glaze
-
Is Sodium Propionate safe in this dessert?
Bad
Sodium Propionate is used here as preservative. Sodium propionate is a synthetic preservative used to inhibit mold growth. Its synthetic nature raises concerns about quality and safety.
Role in formula: preservative
Original: sodium propionate
How we score
Our safety scores and ingredient breakdowns are based on regulatory and scientific sources. See Data sources & methodology and How Zerotox works for full details.
Product info
Product ID: 2358847
More from this brand: Bakery Fresh Goodness products in Zerotox
Similar products: dessert in Zerotox database
Allergens detected: egg , milk , soy , wheat
Report / complain: You may report errors or complain about this product or its formulation to hello [at] zeroto.app . Published for transparency.